• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
(914) 220-1086

Law Offices of Thomas L. Gallivan, PLLC

Just another WordPress site

  • Home
  • About
    • Attorney Profiles
      • Daniel F. Gallivan
      • Thomas L. Gallivan
      • James C. Freeman
      • Andrew J. Gilbride
    • Testimonials
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
      • Car Accident Lawyers
      • Pedestrian Accident Lawyers
      • Slip & Fall Lawyers
      • Truck Accident Lawyers
      • Wrongful Death Lawyers
      • Motorcycle Accident Lawyers
      • Uber Accident Lawyers
    • Nursing Home Abuse
      • Bedsores and Pressure Ulcers
      • Bruises and Cuts
      • Elopement
      • Falls & Broken Bones
      • Group Home Abuse
      • Infections
      • Malnutrition
      • Physical Abuse
    • Criminal Defense
    • Medical Malpractice
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Videos
    • Notable Cases
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • About
    • Attorney Profiles
      • Daniel F. Gallivan
      • Thomas L. Gallivan
      • James C. Freeman
      • Andrew J. Gilbride
    • Testimonials
  • Practice Areas
    • Personal Injury
      • Car Accident Lawyers
      • Pedestrian Accident Lawyers
      • Slip & Fall Lawyers
      • Truck Accident Lawyers
      • Wrongful Death Lawyers
      • Motorcycle Accident Lawyers
      • Uber Accident Lawyers
    • Nursing Home Abuse
      • Bedsores and Pressure Ulcers
      • Bruises and Cuts
      • Elopement
      • Falls & Broken Bones
      • Group Home Abuse
      • Infections
      • Malnutrition
      • Physical Abuse
    • Criminal Defense
    • Medical Malpractice
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Videos
    • Notable Cases
  • Contact Us
Call
Contact
Blog
Home  /  Personal Injury Law  /  Second Department Reduces Damages in Suffolk County Car Accident Suit

Second Department Reduces Damages in Suffolk County Car Accident Suit

by Law Offices of Thomas L. Gallivan, PLLC 09 Jan2015

Cicola v. County of Suffolk, 2014 NY Slip Op 06293, involves a Suffolk County car accident in which an official vehicle being driven by an employee of Suffolk County hit the plaintiff’s vehicle, injuring him. At trial Mr. Cicola was able to prove that the accident resulted from negligence, and further was able to defeat the defendant’s attempts to convince the jury that his injuries were largely pre-existing and simply exacerbated by the accident. After the plaintiff’s win, the defendants appealed, seeking to have the verdict dismissed. They lost – the verdict stood. But, without much explanation or legal reasoning, the Appellate Division, Second Department, ordered damages reduced.

We opened with the brief summary of the case because there is not much more legally relevant information in the Second Department’s opinion. The defendants lost numerous motions. The jury found the plaintiff’s expert more credible than the defense expert. Defendants moved to have the verdict dismissed as “against the weight of the evidence,” They lost this attempt as well. Their appeal also largely fell flat, as they were unable to get the jury verdict imposing damages set aside. But the defendants were ultimately successful in having the Appellate Division forcibly lower the jury’s damage award.

It bears a paragraph to take a close look at those awards. Mr. Cicola (who injured his back in the accident) won from the jury two damage awards: $325,000 for “past pain and suffering” and $250,000 for “future pain and suffering.” The Second Department did not simply lower these damages. Rather, it directed that there would be a new trial solely on the issue of damages (not liability) unless the plaintiff agreed to a reduction to $150,000 for past pain and suffering, and $100,000 for future pain and suffering. Of course, because the court indicated that it would not be friendly to any higher amounts a second trial may lead, to the plaintiff may have felt compelled to accept the lowered damages.

On its face, the allowance made for a court to lower damages awarded by a jury may seem contrary to the immense faith we put into the civil jury system. To this jury, after hearing all of the evidence, this accident leading to a serious injury warranted the award given. Yet the Appellate Court disagreed.

The appellate court cites to CPLR 5501(c). This law allows appellate courts (specifically the mid-level appellate courts of the state, the so-called Appellate Divisions) to alter an award of money damages through the above-described “stipulate or new trial” process if the court finds the award to be “excessive or inadequate if it deviates materially from what would be reasonable compensation.”

The concept of “reasonableness” is a common one in law, and typically a body of case law has been built up determining when something is or is not reasonable depending on the context in which the reasonableness concept is used. No lawyer would condemn a reasonableness analysis – but the Second Department might have done a service to future plaintiffs, defendants, and their attorneys by providing a bit more context as to why this award of damages was truly “excessive.”

Posted in: Personal Injury Law, Motor Vehicle Accidents, Municipal Liability

Primary Sidebar

Get In Touch

Practice Areas

Personal Injury

  • Wrongful Death
  • Motor Vehicle Accidents
  • Trucking Accidents
  • Pedestrian Accidents
  • Construction Accidents
  • Scaffolding Accidents
  • Slip, Trip & Falls (Premises Liability)
  • Negligent Supervision at a School or Day Care
  • Sidewalk Falls
  • Elevator Accidents
  • Train and Subway Accidents

Nursing Home Neglect & Abuse

  • Bedsores (Pressure Ulcers)
  • Falls & Fractures
  • Malnutrition and Dehydration
  • Physical and Sexual Abuse
  • Wandering & Elopement
  • Unexplained Bruises and Cuts
  • Infection
  • Choking Incidents
  • Medication Errors
  • Group Homes
  • Assisted Living Facilities

Criminal/DWI Defense

  • DWI (Driving While Intoxicated)
  • Criminal Defense
  • Traffic Violations
  • DMV Refusal Hearings
  • Sex Crimes
  • Shoplifting & Larceny
  • Assault & Vehicular Assault
  • Drug Possession
  • Drug Sales
  • Weapons Charges
  • Domestic Violence
  • How is a DWI Defined in New York?
  • Is the Driver’s License Confiscated Immediately Upon a DWI Arrest?

Medical Malpractice

  • Failure to Diagnose Cancer
  • Birth Injuries (Gynecological, Obstetrical)
  • Medication Errors
  • Surgical Errors
  • Gastric Bypass Surgery Errors
  • Emergency Room Errors
  • Failure to Diagnose Heart Attack or Stroke
  • Cerebral Palsy
  • Erbs Palsy Birth Injury

Trusts + Estates

  • Wills & Trusts
  • Divorce, Child Support, Custody Issues
  • Elder Law
  • Estate Planning
  • Guardianships
  • Medicaid-Planning
  • Power of Attorney / Health Care Proxy
  • Probate and Estate Administration
  • Surrogate Court Litigation
  • Real Estate
  • Business Formation
  • Wills
  • Will Contests

View All Practice Areas

View All Blogs

CLIENT TESTIMONIALS

" Last year I was injured in an accident, and for the first time, needed the advice of an attorney regarding how to proceed. I was referred to Thomas Gallivan through a family member who is a lawyer in Massachusetts. I am beyond pleased with how Thomas handled my case. He was knowledgeable, professional, and although the case was not as straightforward as some, he used every resource to ensure a positive outcome. Thomas communicated with me regularly and I felt completely informed and confident in his ability. He expertly negotiated a fair settlement that I was very happy with. The entire experience was extremely positive, during a stressful time for me. Thank you Thomas. "

Melanie

" Attorney Thomas Gallivan is a wonderful attorney!! I particularly liked his professionalism, consistency, always kept us updated on the case, and available upon request. He worked extremely hard and was persistent on getting the best settlement in a timely matter. I truly appreciated his prompt responsiveness to emails and phone calls. The office staff was very pleasant and made sure to get messages to him asap. Glad we chose this law firm, would highly recommend and in the event that we ever need an attorney again, Gallivan & Gallivan would be my primary choice. "

Katherine R.

" I was a passenger on a motorcycle and ended up falling off the back of the bike due to the driver acting like an idiot. I fell off at a high rate of speed and was very banged up. Fractured wrist and road rash down my back and elbows. I am lucky I didnt die. Not knowing what to do I contacted Thomas and he could not have been anymore helpful!! He went out of his way to meet with me. He actually came to my house for the initial consultation. I know nothing about law or what my options even were. He took me through everything step by step. "

Colin W.

View All Testimonials

245 Main St Suite 450 White Plains, NY 10601

Phone:
(914) 220-1086

Fax:
(516) 394-4229

555 5th Ave 14th Floor
New York, NY 10017

Toll Free:
(855) 228-7369

(By Appointment Only)

1370 RXR Plaza
Uniondale, NY 11556

Phone:
(914) 594-6820

Fax:
(516) 394-4229

12 1st St
Riverhead, NY 11901

Phone:
(914) 825-5855

Fax:
(516) 394-4229

Footer

  • Home
  • About
  • Practice Areas
  • Blog
  • Resources
  • Contact Us

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING

Copyright © 2022, Law Offices of Thomas L. Gallivan, PLLC